Legal
This is a working group for legal issues relating to Drupal. That includes licensing questions and planning. It should not be used as a legal advice forum; for that, consult a lawyer. If you actually have information from a lawyer about an issue that would be relevant to Drupal, however, that would be welcome.
Please be sure to read the FAQ before posting!
Can contributed modules contain non-GPL data (other than css and images)?
Can contributed modules contain non-GPL data (other than css and images)?
I have a module to contribute that creates and populates a taxonomy vocabulary. Can the vocabulary terms be distributed under a different license than the code? Could that license also cover the vocabulary terms as a group after installation?
Thanks.
Selling software/service based on Drupal
If someone uses Drupal to build a custom "software as a service" web app (an example mght be basecamp [http://basecamphq.com/]), is there any way to prevent a competitor from getting acces to the custom code or configuration used to create it and starting a competing service?
Can I have subscription on the site built using Drupal module & theme?
Hi!
Is it legal to have subscription based web site built on Drupal? I won't distribute anything by will have users visit the site.
Any idea?
Driving adoption of Drupal in large enterprises
This topic will be of interest to many people across various organizations today who are deliberating on whether to adopt drupal or not and if so to what extent.
We are a group of Drupal enthusiasts within a large IT services provider interested in using the drupal platform to configure and create simple tools to help the various teams within the organization in day to day activities.
Public domain material in d.org CVS?
I'd like to release a couple of themes through d.org. All my themes are built using Eric Meyer's browser reset stylesheet which is in the public domain. I'm also thinking about incorporating public domain images in my themes, such as photographs from the NASA archives. At the same time I'm aware of the restriction that only GPL'd files are allowed into the repository. What am I to do?
Privacy policy for *.Drupal.org
There is a very old issue in the webmaster's queue (http://drupal.org/node/178776) about creating a privacy policy. With the docs team gearing up for a lot of work and survey action, bekasu felt we really needed to do some CYA and so she wrote up a comprehensive privacy policy. I've attached it to the issue and wanted to point this group to it since we need to obviously get legal review as well as figuring out what we really need in there and what we can chop off. I'm in no position to have anything meaningful to say, so hand it over to legal.
New draft of the Drupal Trademark Policy
It took several iterations and various lawyers but here is another draft of what will become the Drupal Trademark Policy. We did our best to incorporate many of the suggestions that were provided in response to the previous draft. As a result, this is a substantial update and I encourage you to read it carefully.
Module that requires SOAP connection to 3rd party closed source .NET API
Hello
We have been asked to write a module that will connect to a 3rd party API on a separate server, using SOAP. The API is part of a closed source .NET application. The module cannot function (or even be installed) unless it retrieves data from the 3rd party API.
The license agreement for the 3rd party software strictly prohibits distribution and/or unlicensed access to the API, documentation etc.
Can/should we upgrade the CC license on the handbooks?
There is an old issue in the docs queue (http://drupal.org/node/219053) about upgrading the CC license from 2.0 to 3.0. I'm not sure a) whether it is needed or b) if we could legally do it. Feedback one way or the other would be great so we can close that issue.
Drupal API iPhone app
bertboerland recently found that someone has created a Drupal API iPhone app. In the iTunes Store, it is sold for $1.99 and says "Copyright 2008 Sehat Rosny." I'm pretty sure this is a big no-no since on api.drupal.org, it says specifically, "All source code and documentation on this site is released under the terms of the GNU General Public License, version 2 and later. Drupal is a registered trademark of Dries Buytaert." I e-mailed Apple about the violation so hopefully it is removed. I like the idea, but it's just not done correctly. Note the author also has done the same for PHP and Apache documentation. I haven't looked into either of those to see if they are violations as well.
Q. How is attribution maintained in contributions
We have created a fairly involved Drupal distribution that we use to build client sites. Currently we are using the database copy method to start new sites. We have been working on a true installation profile so the recipe can be distributed the Drupal community.
A lot of work has gone into this and the main thing we want to avoid is someone taking all this work and claiming it as their own. Basically, we want to maintain attribution back to the authors.
Re-licensing own code
After reading thru the CVS pages and licensing FAQ's - there's one thing I'm not clear on (this is more a general question rather than a drupal one).
If you have a drupal module licensed under Apache 2.0 it can't go in since that is not GPLv2 compatible - that I understand.
But - as the copyright holder - can such a license just be switched? Where no others have contributed - can I just switch out Apache 2.0 to GPLv2 ?
Would it have to apply for a given version and on (the version where the license changed) ?
Licensing of configuration files?
I'm doing a bunch of work on the apachesolr module at the moment. One area where I'm really t a loss is how to treat the .xml configuration files. There original "example" files are part of the Apache 2.0-licensed distribution of Solr. So, while our current versions bear only little resemblance to these examples, they are clearly "derived" from them. In fact, it's hard to imagine a practical way one could generate a configuration file that is not "derived" form the example files provided (since the docs tend to be a little scarce).
Q: Freelance Drupal Developer Questions
Hi Everyone, I'm new and would appreciate a little light shone on a few things for me...
I am an Australian budding feelance web designer and couldn't believe my luck when I stumbled across Drupal! I'm not much of a programmer you see so to be able to create dynamic content this easily is a dream come true. However... After reading the legal FAQ's I have a few concerns.
Drupal GPL 2+ and compatibility with Apache, MIT, Freeware License
Hello:
We've developed a drupal module that uses 3rd party php libraries and a jQuery plugin. The module serves the purpose of stamping an uploaded
PDF documented for a drupal user.
The php libraries and iQuery plugin used are
FPDF 1.53 (http://www.fpdf.org) - This is a freeware license
FPDI 1.2 (http://www.setasign.de/products/pdf-php-solutions/fpdi) - Licensed under Apache License, Version 2.0
FPDF_TPL 1.1.1 (http://www.setasign.de/support/manuals/fpdf-tpl/introduction) - Licensed under Apache License, Version 2.0
Drupal Association Donations
So the short term is close to pass from December 2006 - any updated plans to incorporate in places other than Belgium?
Is Drupal a registered US 501(c)(3)?
No, as stated above, the Drupal Association has been incorporated in Belgium. We will explore ways of having sister / daughter organizations in different countries and what that means for different tax implications, but is not likely something we can tackle in the short term....
Drupal, GPL and module development
Hi,
I am currently looking into using Drupal as a framework for Web
Application development. However, I was hoping that I could get some
clarification as to my potential obligations for modules that I would
develop under contract for my clients. My understanding according to
Licensing FAQ Question 8 (http://drupal.org/licensing/faq#q8) is that my
obligation under the GPL extends to delivering the module to the client
under a GPL license and that I am under no obligation to distribute it any
further.
Is that a correct reading of your intent with regard to that FAQ question
Drupal trademark policy draft
As announced, I've been working with the Software Freedom Law Center, lawyers, and the Drupal Association on drafting a public trademark policy for use of the Drupal trademark. We're all happy with the current draft, so this is the time to open it up to the community to get further input and feedback. Please read it carefully, and let us know if you have comments or suggestions. This policy is obviously an important one as more and more people starting abusing the Drupal trademark. Thanks!
Q: Can I relicence a BSD project to GPL, so as to host it on D.O CVS?
Hello,
I am working on a base-theme yui-grids-framework.
First of all: there is such a project on D.o. already, but that one is a) dead, and b) suffering from the same thing I want to solve.
YUI grids is dristributed under BSD. From my tiny bit of legal knowledge, I recall that BSD can be relicenced as GPL.
In that case, I can simply do so, and then upload the results to Drupal.org CVS.
Court Ruling Is a Victory for Supporters of Free Software (NY Times)
A New York Times article "Ruling Is a Victory for Supporters of Free Software" (August 14, 2008, NY Times Business section, p. C7) reports a decision upholding an open source license that had lost in the lower court. A pdf of the decision is available at the Findlaw website, at URL
http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=fed&navby=title&v...
This is not a broadly worded decision but the outcome points in the right direction, toward enforceability of an open source license.











