This group is for peer review of Drupal projects. When we ask for and accept constructive critique, and when we take the time to go through someone else's work, everyone wins with better projects and practical knowledge.
Have a new module and want some feedback or a code review? Created a new theme and would like people to look at it for suggestions? Have an installation profile you'd like others to review? A site you're working on (with detailed implementation notes) and want opinions? This is the place! Note: Absolutely no job postings.
Request a review or find projects in your area of interest for which people would like a review.
Kicking it old Skool!
I know what it feels like to have your hard work critiqued, piles of issues to solve and to deal with some of the hardest discussions and posts we can have. I know the many hours spent, sacrificing time with our loved ones, time without sleep or the so many other things we give up to do our part.
Read moreNew Initiatives For Code Review Process
There are several initiatives currently being discussed in the Code Review Group aimed at reducing the backlog in the full project application queue (currently approaching seven weeks). These are briefly summarized at http://groups.drupal.org/node/154509. I am very much interested in hearing from people outside the small group of individuals who regularly participate in the code review group.
Code review
For how to do code reviews and to help out by reviewing first-time project releasers, see Code Review group.
Drupal.org Process: Bringing idea to production.
The draft policy, procedures and requirements for bringing *.drupal.org initiatives onto the live sites are published here:
Process for getting changes deployed on drupal.org
Drupal.org development guidelines
Hopefully as ideas are generated and refined through the Prairie Initiative and people start implementing solutions, implementors can be proactive rather than reactive to the process and requirements necessary for improving Drupal.org.
Read moreModule Approval Process will KILL Drupal.
We have almost 247 individuals to be reviewed. Thus I hang myself out there put My neck on the line and am demanding change. If this ruins My reputation, then so be it.
Ok, so I started this conversation with an attention grabbing headline, but I truely believe it. I have had so many people come in and ask about the status of their code going from sandbox to release. The problem, people waiting a week or more for their project to even get a response from those few brave soles who have volunteered for the review process.
Read moreAbout the Peer Review group
Open source, open collaboration, open feedback!
This is a group for peer review of modules, themes, installation profiles, features…. Have a new module and want some feedback? Created a new theme and would like people to look at it for suggestions? Have an installation profile you'd like others to review? This is the place to seek that out!
Read more
Code Review Sprint at DrupalCon Chicago 2011?
As I updated all the CVS applications tonight (with some great help), I couldn't help but think that its still so unwieldy. So, I was thinking about maybe organizing a code review sprint at DrupalCon Chicago next week focused on the new Full Project applications.
It would be super cool to get applicants and reviewers paired up in person.
So, I am wondering if anyone has any thoughts or suggestions, especially on logistics. Also, my bandwidth is pretty low so maybe someone is willing to help out on this.
Issues requesting Peer Review
All issues requesting peer review use the peer-review tag (with a dash, like this group). People can also optionally focus the review they are looking for with tags such as code-review, ux-review, etc.
Read more
Features Selector
Hello,
Just finished a module whose main purpose is to maintain a map of existing Drupal UI form elements responsible for setting or listing something that could be exported to a feature related to its particular features components. It then displays a widget in that place for selecting to which feature this component is intended to belong.
Mainly functional for selecting which variables you want to export to a feature if you don't know which strongarm component that was you changed in the form you just submitted. At this time it works only with Features, but i see possibilities of other uses and the API is capable of that. Selecting whatever in the Drupal UI for other modules.
Your feedback wanted.
Matej
Combine Peer Review and Code Review groups
I noticed that the Peer Review group is being revitalized and the mission expandedand there is a movement for a more structured peer review of modules program, which is awesome.
Read moreContributed Module Code Reviews
Code review of existing contributed modules is frequently cited as a means to improving the quality of existing contributed modules. However, the task of performing a code review falls somewhere between documentation, writing and reviewing patches, reviewing CVS applications, and creating new modules.
This is a proposal to elevate the visibility of module review, and make it easier for newcomers to perform module reviews.
Read more
Code review outside of the repository access application process
I'm writing that new developers can ask for a code review quite apart from the application review process, but i don't have much i can tell them except ask in IRC and (suggested by beejeebus ask in a g.d.o group on a topic related to your module.
Should we try to create a clearinghouse?
A "code review requested" tag for issues– or projects?
Any other places that exist or ideas for what should or should not be created?
First patch for FCKeditor support hit Wysiwyg's queue
I have spent the last hours to get a first draft of FCKeditor support in Wysiwyg Editor module.
http://drupal.org/node/282717
It's still very rough and dirty, but it outlines what can be done and what needs to be done for multiple editor support in Drupal via one API module.
Now I badly need some feedback from folks that are interested in centralized Wysiwyg editor support, who know jQuery + JavaScript, and who might have ideas and suggestions on how to solve the outlined design challenges. Of course, all editor module maintainers are implicitly more than welcome.
Cuentos para Dormir: usability, navigation, theming and taxonomies
Hello all, here I introduce you my cuentos infantiles site.
It is a site written in spanish, where I post original short stories for children, created to educate in values and ethics. It is not a commercial site that has been in production over half a year, and right now I would like to receive feedback about these points I am concerned about:
- Usability and navigation: I am not sure if they are clear and simple enough, nor even if the site's goals are well showm.
- Theming: I wonder if the selected theme is adequate for the content and structure of the site. Especifically I would like feedback regarding the usage of a 3 column layout.
- Taxonomies presentation. Taxonomies are key for this site, as taxonomy and tagadelics are the core orgonization of the site. However, I would like to receive feedack about how taxonomies are presented and displayed
Also, if someone want to provide suggestions of useful blocks and so on, I would be glad to read them
thank you very much for your feedback!
Should someone write a "Submit as" module?
Yesterday I downloaded and played with the Drigg module. Among its features is an option to let a privileged role submit content as a different user. The list of spoof users is also an administration option. The motivation for this is clear... it lets a handful of people easily make a site look like a bustling community. This is great for jumpstarting your Drigg site (which is designed to be a Digg clone), but how ethical is it?
Read more
PLAY7.com in beta - Southern California's Intimate Theatre Guide
This is my first-ever drupal site. I started by trying to duplicate an ASB VBScript site that a long-lost developer did for me. When the old site's database corrupted a few weeks ago, it naturally accelerated my development of the drupal site. I pulled everything together and posted the beta as quickly as I could.
Read more
Search Marketing Company
I'm starting to build a search engine company primarily targetting small and medium businesses to a) Transition to Drupal and b) To get their SEO/SEM business. I wanted to bounce of the theme http://www.surgeboom.com. We are not even ready at alpha stage but I think the theme is coming along.
Would love to have feedback.
Osho Community
Hi,
I am newbie to drupal and just launched (beta) my first drupal site. http://www.oshocommunity.com.
Need suggestions and ideas to improve the site.
Thanks & Regards,
Kirtan
Happy Drupaller
PetLove.eu social networking for pets!
Hi, I'm currently working on a social networking site, for pets!! PetLove, I only work on it on my free time, and it´s been more than three months since I started.
Sorry, but it´s only in Spanish (i´ll work on the un-translation as soon as i´m done with the basic functionality of the site, and if anyone wants to help with other languages... :D ).
I would love to start receiving some feedback meanwhile.
Thanks
First attempt at an Ed site www.cor.robonline.id.au
Just started with Drupal and am working on 3 sites at once. With this site I am attempting to provide targeted resources for students studying a real estate course we offer by distance. You will have to log in to get past the front page so use student/student to see the site as students will see it when it goes live in early Feb.
Read more