Key pros and cons of Drupal vs Joomla

Events happening in the community are now at Drupal community events on www.drupal.org.
zeal's picture

Drupal
* Rock solid & high quality platform
* Real multi-site-feature (only one installation for several sites)
* Any Kind of user groups & user permissions, OpenId compliant in Version 6
* Can run membership and community sites, not only CMS etc
* Powerful templating system. Any XHTML or CSS template can be easily converted to Drupal.
* Drupal needs a little time investment to realize all the huge possibilities of Drupal
* Clear, high quality code and API (easy to integrate with other solutions etc)
* Flexibility and no known limitations
* Many high profile sites use Drupal (e.g.: MTV UK, BBC, the Onion, Nasa, Greenpeace UK, New york observer. )

Joomla
* If you are not techy its good to start
* Easy install & setup with your mouse
* Easy learning curve
* Cannot integrate other scripts etc. to your site
* Generally you cannot create high-end sites, without investing huge amount
* No SEO out of the box, URLs are not search engine friendly.
* Server resources utilization is more compared to drupal
* Only one site per installation
* No Single Log-in to several sites
* No User groups & permissions
* More intuitive administration user interface
* Some polished modules for things like calendars, polls, etc.
* Modules cost you money

System Requirements:

* Drupal can work with MySQL and Postgres while Joomla is known to support only MySQL
* Drupal can work with Apache or IIS while Joomla is known to support only Apache
* Joomla support SSL logins and SSL pages. Drupal not known to support it.

Site Management

* Drupal has free add on for Workflow management. Joomla not known to have one.
* Drupal has inbuilt Translation manager. Joomla has a Free ad on for the same
* Drupal has more   granular priviledge managment

Interoperability:

* Drupal has iCal support [Add on] , Joomla not known to have one.
* Drupal is XHTML Complaint. Joomla not known to be one.
* Drupal has excellent versioning and Audit trail which Joomla lacks

Comments

My opinion

zeal's picture

Drupal is much better than Joomla.

Drupal Rocks! --zeal

Drupal Rocks! --zeal

SSL

pshahmumbai's picture

Joomla support SSL logins and SSL pages. Drupal not known to support it.

http://drupal.org/project/securepages

Joomla runs on IIS

xtfer's picture

While Im not likely to recommend Joomla over Drupal, it does run fine on IIS 6+.

That said, Joomla has some left over PHP4 coding in it that can create minor headaches for the uninitiated. Also, I wouldn't call its admin interface user friendly, its clunky in its own way.

Drupal I

Aussawinning's picture

Drupal I Cheer!

Cyberyogi

opensense's picture

Just reading through the drupal forum i came across a post which was discussing about a comparison between drupal and joomla.

I have my assessment of both the systems on various aspects.

FLEXIBILITY: drupal is awsome when it comes to flexibility, while Joomla is not that flexible.

THEME: the joomla theme is quite too much attached with the joomla core so you do not have complete control over the theme. Drupal give you power to do just anything to your theme.

COST: When it comes to development the joomla is going to pinch your pockets with much more bucks than drupal, as the plugin and extensions are mostly not free. In case of drupal its all free.

MULTIPLE ROLES: Joomla does not offer you any more extra user roles but drupal gives you any number of user roles with different permissions. Seems perfect for membership websites.

POWER: With CCK, panal, and views you limited only by your imaginations about what can be done on drupal. No such powerful modules in joomla.

MULTILINGUAL: Drupal is a perfect solution for multilingual websites with I18n module. Joomla though offers some multilingual features but not as exhaustive as drupal.

SYNC: Most important feature is the different modules sync very well with each other to add functionality to each other but joomla has modules which are standalone in itself.

http://www.zooinn.com/2009/10/drupal-and-joomla-a-comparison/

Drupal vs Joomla

rakesh falke's picture

Hi All,

Drupal is much better than Joomla.

no doubt about it!!!

Regards
Rakesh Falke
DforDrupal

Drupal > Joomla

CaseyA's picture

I personally favor Drupal (which is probably why I'm hanging out here), but here are some of my pros/cons, which I posted on Quora (link below).

DRUPAL

Pros:
- Extremely flexible
- Developer friendly
- Strong SEO capabilities
- Enterprise friendly
- Stability
- Active community willing to help
- Tons of helpful modules built by the community
- Multisite and multidev capabilities
- Quality code & API

Cons:
- Steeper learning curve
- Lack of easy to implement themes (I'd say Wordpress is best for that)
- Need to add modules for each site

Drupal can handle pretty much any site from a personal blog to a full blown enterprise website. There are many high profile sites that use Drupal. I will add more info with links in my resources below.

JOOMLA

Pros:
- Relatively user-friendly (far behind WP though)
- Extension variability
- Easy installation

Cons:
- Learning curve, similar to Drupal
- Lacks SEO capabilities
- Limited ACL support

Thoughts? Things I should add?

Quora Link: http://www.quora.com/Drupal-or-Joomla-Pros-and-cons

India

Group notifications

This group offers an RSS feed. Or subscribe to these personalized, sitewide feeds:

Hot content this week