Posted by klausi on September 28, 2012 at 2:04pm
We have currently 27 RTBC project applications that need a final check by a code review administrator. I am quite busy with the review bonus program so I don't have time to review/approve all of them.
You can help: if you are a code review administrator it would be cool if you could checkout at least one RTBC application per week (or more, or less - any help is appreciated).
If you are a regular reviewer and you think you can add value as a code review administrator just contact me. If you just started as new contributor and want to earn fame and glory as application reviewer just contact me as well - I'll help you get started and mentor you to finally become a code review administrator. You can find me on IRC in #drupal-codereview.
Comments
uff, sorry for leaving you
uff, sorry for leaving you alone :(
I'll try to get some fixed tomorrow
But I'd also really appreciate if there are some more people helping with this
I'd like to become a code
I'd like to become a code review administrator, although I have never review a project before.
我的drupal博客Think in Drupal
Great initiative! You should
Great initiative! You should start by doing lots of reviews (and reading the reviews of others).
Anyone with some module writing skills can do reviews.
knaddison blog | Morris Animal Foundation
How many reviews that i have
How many reviews that i have to do before I could apply "code review administrator"?
我的drupal博客Think in Drupal
There's no specific number
There's no specific number because it depends on the quality/consistency of the reviews. It might be as low as 30. It might be as high as a few hundred.
knaddison blog | Morris Animal Foundation
B - O - T - S
Bots
Bots
Bots
Status of the review queue
Is it going better than before ?
Right now there are 25 RTBC modules on the queue.
I try to help as best as I can but clearing the queue is not an easy task... some modules are quite long and require around one hour to install, analyse and send the feedback.
Regarding bots, I think that a bot system could really speed up some precious minutes on the process. I don't think it couldn't be completely automatized, as false positives are a common problem on auto reviews.
cube inspire - web design and web development solutions !
As of 2014-06-19, RTBC: 71, PARreview bonus: 12.
As of 2014-06-19, the number of projects in the full Project Applications issue queue is RTBC is 71 and the number of projects with status "Needs review" on the PARreview bonus list is 12.
I'll try to help our with doing reviews, but it looks like the real bottleneck is the final review by a git administrator?
I currently see a few
I currently see a few problems.
Yes, there is the bottleneck with the git admins right now. That is why most of them only really work from those with review bonuses, and why klausi put out a call to action to get a few more on board (I think two were recently promoted). While not everyone agrees with the bonus program, it does get more eyes on modules, and I think those get bonuses are more likely to followup and fix problems and end up with better modules in the end.
The other problem is that a lot of modules are ending up at RTBC that have obvious, major problems with them. Either big API issues or security problems (usually XSS). More good reviews of the Needs Review items are needed.
Yes, although we recently
Yes, although we recently added 2 new git administrators the RTBC list is still long. Would you like to help out as administrator? Keep collecting your reviews on your mentoring page and after being a regular reviewer we can promote you :-)
Yes, I would like to help out as admin
Yes, I would like to help out as admin, but first I need to get git vetted access. Looking at the shape of the queue, that may take a while
:-(.Helping out with reviewing
Helping out with reviewing the Needs Review items will both help you get reviews under your belt and also get your project closer to being fully reviewed.